Featured Flavors

Strawberry Lemonade NEW!!
Take a bit of summer with this tangy and tart treat! Lemon cake with strawberry preserve filling and a strawberry lemon-y buttercream!

Awesome Almond NEW!!
Lightly flavored almond cake almond pastry cream filling and almond crunch frosting! (Delicious with a drizzle of chcolate!)

Razzleberry NEW!!
Takes like pie....only better! Blueberry Burst cake with a strawberry/raspberry compote filling and a tartly-sweet blackberry cream cheese frosting!

S'mores NEW!!
Chocolate cake stuffed with marshmallow fluff and topped with a graham cracker buttercream....you'll definitely want some more!!!

Breakfast Buffet NEW!!
For all you breakfast lovers out there! Sweetly swirled cinnamon and sugar cake filled with orange creamsicle filling topped with maple cream cheese frosting...and of course a piece of candied bacon!

Triple Chocolate NEW!!
Chocolate cake with a creamy chocolate ganache filling, topped with our silky Choc-O-Holic Chip frosting!

Bombshell
Created for the lovely ladies of Bombshell Burlesque. Moist chocolate cake with a decadent raspberry preserve and Chambord filling accompanied by luscious raspberry buttercream.

Star Luxe
Cinnamon-Espresso cake with creamy mocha frosting topped with a coffee bean Just like your favorite morning coffee drink!

Red Velvet
Belly's Bake Shop #1 seller! Radiant red velvet cake with dreamy cream cheese frosting. Melts in your mouth!

Chocolate Elvis
Chocolate cake, gooey cinnamon-banana center, paired with smooth and creamy peanut butter frosting

All On Black
Dark devils food cake with rich choc-o-holic frosting

Lemon Lover
For the true lemon fanatic! Light fluffy lemon cake with lemon curd filling and lemon butter frosting

Strawbelly Shortcake
Layer upon layer of fluffy white cake and strawberry preserves with fresh strawberry slices, topped with silky buttercream frosting

Canadian
Rich maple infused vanilla cake with a decadent maple cream frosting

Cookies N Cream
Chocolate or Vanilla cake paired with our fabulous 'cookies n cream' frosting

Fruit Tart
Sweet vanilla bean cake with pastry cream filling and your choice of mixed fruit topping! Perfectly refreshing for summer bbq's!

Banana Nut-Fluff Cake
Banana loaf cake with whipped cream frosting; sprinkled with toasted walnuts!

Pina Colada
Light and fluffy pineapple infused cake with a hint of rum extract topped with coconut cream frosting and sprinkles of toasted coconut! It's a summer vacation for your taste buds!
(Submitted by 2010 Flavor Contest Winner: Robin Sweet)

Peanut Butter & Jelly
A grown-up take on the classic peanut butter & jelly sandwich that we all grew up loving! Silky smooth peanut-buttery frosting tops a Concord grape jelly filled white cake!
(Submitted by 2010 Flavor Contest Winner: Mark "Sam The Mailman" Harris)

 

Create Your Own

Cake Flavors Frosting Flavors Fillings

Red Velvet
Vanilla Bean
Chocolate
Lemon
Maple
Banana
Almond *
Orange *
Yellow Butter Cake
Cinnamon Espresso
Blueberry Burst *
Cinnamon Sugar
Strawberry *
Pound Cake

Belly's Buttercream
Cream Cheese
Choc-O-Holic
Choc-O-Holic Chip *
Mint Chocolate Chip
Raspberry Buttercream
Maple Cream Cheese
Almond Crunch *
Peanut Butter
Lemon Butter Frosting
Nutella Buttercream *
Cookies N Cream
Coconut Cream
Raspberry Buttercream
Orange Creamsicle *
Strawberry Buttercream
Blackberry Cream Cheese *
White Choc Mac Nut Buttercream *

Lemon Curd
Lime Curd
Nutella Cream *
Strawberry preserves
Raspberry preserves
Orange Marmelade *
Orange Creamsicle *
Pastry Cream
Cookies N Cream
Razzleberry Compote*
Marshmallow Fluff
Cheesecake

* - Indicates new cake flavor, frosting flavor, or filling!